Telegram, an essential communication tool for millions, finds itself under scrutiny once again. Copyright holders have long expressed concerns about the lack of enforcement on the platform, and recent actions suggest Telegram is responding. Subscribers to Z-Library’s popular channel recently noticed that several of the shadow library’s messages have been removed “due to copyright infringement.”
From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.
With approximately a billion active monthly users worldwide, Telegram is one of the most used messaging services.
The communication platform helps to connect people from all over the globe, with optional end-to-end encryption providing improved security compared to some other players in the market.
Telegram can also be an excellent medium to broadcast messages to a wider audience. Through dedicated one-way channels, people can share news, status updates, and emergency alerts, for example.
Illegal Activities
However, like any technology, Telegram has its dark side. It’s been used to facilitate illegal activities, including drug trafficking, fraud, and the spread of child abuse images. While much of this occurs beyond the company’s purview, Telegram has faced criticism for not doing enough to combat these activities.
Last month, the company’s CEO, Pavel Durov, was arrested at a French airport as part of a criminal investigation. According to several reports, Telegram is accused of facilitating drug trafficking, fraud, and the spread of child abuse images.
Although copyright infringement wasn’t cited as a reason for the arrest, Telegram has attracted criticism from rightsholders in the past. The service has been flagged a “notorious” piracy market on numerous occasions and was previously listed on the EU’s “piracy watch list”.
These complaints go beyond mere warnings. Earlier this year, a Spanish court ordered Internet providers to block the service in its entirety due to copyright issues. While this blockade was averted at the eleventh hour following fierce backlash, the pressure is on.
Z-Library, Telegram, and the DMCA
Telegram isn’t oblivious to the critique. The company accepts DMCA takedown notices and regularly removes copyrighted content, when asked. This means that if rights holders spot infringing content being posted publicly, they can take action.
It’s unknown how responsive Telegram is to these takedown notices, but the recent disappearance of several posts in the official “Z-Library Official” channel, suggests that Telegram isn’t sitting still.
With more than half a million subscribers, Z-Library has one of the more popular channels on Telegram. The shadow library is also the target in a U.S. criminal investigation and has had hundreds of domain names seized over the past two years.
Z-Library uses Telegram to send updates to users, including the availability of new domain names. That’s a source of frustration for book publishers and U.S. law enforcement, who are trying to make the site inaccessible. While Z-Library hasn’t folded yet, Telegram is taking action.
Telegram Removes Z-Library Posts
The “Z-Library Official” channel currently has 566,893 subscribers and remains online today. Several posts have vanished, however, including this message that was published in response to recent domain seizures.
May 31 message
Although this update didn’t include infringing content, it links to the Z-Library site, which appears to be off limits for Telegram. Over a dozen other posts have met the same fate. These have all been replaced with the following note.
“This message couldn’t be displayed on your device due to copyright infringement”, the updates now read.
The updates don’t mention who requested the removal, but rightsholders or U.S. law enforcement are prime candidates. In either case, Z-Library received the message loud and clear, and it no longer includes direct links to its site in new updates.
“Since recently, the Telegram administration has been blocking posts that contain links to our library. So, we’d like to remind you about the places where you can find the actual links,” the team writes, pointing readers to Wikipedia and Reddit.
The Link Conundrum
Z-Library’s message points users to Wikipedia and Reddit, where links are still accepted, at least for now. On Telegram, there are still plenty of Z-Library links in the comments as well, and even on Z-Library’s official profile page.
At the same time, fraudulent Z-Library copycats are profiting from the link Whack-A-Mole by posting unofficial links. These have also appeared on the official Wikipedia page in the past, and on top of search engine results.
While accessing Z-Library isn’t getting any easier, the site itself doesn’t show any signs of slowing down. Z-Library just started a new “donation drive” to continue to fund their operation. According to the numbers that are available, thousands of dollars have been donated already in just a few days.
Fundraise
From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.
You must be logged in to post a comment.